Legislature(1997 - 1998)
04/18/1997 09:13 AM Senate FIN
| Audio | Topic |
|---|
* first hearing in first committee of referral
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
SB 141 CONCEALED HANDGUN PERMITS
SENATOR GREEN testified on behalf of the bill. SENATOR
TORGERSON MOVED to adopt draft CS version "X" as CSSB
141(FIN). Without objection, it was ADOPTED. Also
testifying were TUCKERMAN BABCOCK, RANDY SMITH, BRUCE
OCKRASSA, MIKE CORKILL, PHIL NASH, ROD CHRISTOPHER,
PATRICK JOHNSON, JOE MICHAUD, BILL JONES, GREGG OLSON,
SCOTT CAMPBELL, HARRIS STUERMER, DIANE BUFFINGTON, BOB
WISEMAN, DUANE BUELL, DICK BISHOP, DEL SMITH, LAUREE
HUGONIN, ART SNOWDEN and ANN CARPENETI. The bill was
HELD for further consideration.
SB 141 CONCEALED HANDGUN PERMITS
SENATOR LYDA GREEN testified on behalf of the bill. She
recalled last year's bill, SB 177, which was vetoed, and
stated that SB 141 addresses some of the same concerns. She
described differences in a proposed CS, version X. It
extended the time frame for issuing a permit from fifteen to
thirty days. Language was also amended to reflect the
intent to not permit felons to ever carry concealed weapons.
Another provision dealt with an instruction book with
pertinent information concerning where it would be legal to
carry concealed by making it consistent with where one could
carry openly. A fourth change related to concerns raised
last year about alcohol. A person carrying concealed would
be prohibited from drinking alcohol in a restaurant. The
last change had to do with permitting peace officers in
Sections 4, 6 and 9. There had been some statewide
objection, but she did not feel it was unreasonable to
include peace officers. The main premise of the bill was
that those permitted to apply for a concealed weapon permit
and the places a person could carry a weapon would be
consistent with those who were permitted to carry openly.
It did not make sense to have a list of prohibitions for
those carrying concealed when one did not exist for those
who simply owned a gun. The consistency would reduce
confusion and make the privilege of carry concealed what it
was intended to be.
SENATOR TORGERSON MOVED to adopt draft CS version "X" as
CSSB 141(FIN). Without objection, it was ADOPTED.
SENATOR ADAMS inquired what was being eliminated in the
qualifications under the repealers. He asked if alcoholics
would be able to get a permit.
SENATOR GREEN responded that a list in federal law of people
prohibited from carrying openly addressed alcohol and drug
abuse. She believed the list was in committee files in a
document from Legal Services dated 3/24/97. SENATOR ADAMS
inquired about the repealer section, specifically AS
18.65.740, and asked for the rationale.
End SFC-97 #115, Side 1, Begin Side 2
TUCKERMAN BABCOCK, Staff, Senator Green, explained that
being convicted of two class A misdemeanors did not prevent
carrying a handgun. If the intent of the legislature was to
prohibit that, it would be a different issue than
specifically trying to address the 6,000 people who have
permits.
SENATOR PARNELL pointed out a difference from last year's
bill in that SB 141 greatly reduced the list of
qualifications and requirements to obtain a permit. He
questioned whether federal law covered those because he was
unsure if it was even enforced in the state. He suggested
including the list in statute. He asked which of the
repealed sections were not covered by federal law.
MR. BABCOCK responded that the list under AS 18.65 related
only to those who apply for a concealed carry permit. It
was a different list from those who could openly carry a
handgun. All current prohibitions for people who openly
carry a handgun would apply to those who applied for a
concealed permit. The bill did not repeal any federal or
state prohibition except those specifically referenced for
the concealed carry and only apply to 6,000 people.
COCHAIR SHARP called for statewide teleconference testimony
next. He asked that testimony be limited to two minutes to
allow everyone an opportunity to testify.
Anchorage:
RANDY SMITH favored the bill. He stated that it puts all
Alaskans on an equal basis. He supported the provision on
page 6, line 2 permitting retired law enforcement officers,
but suggested a two year period for additional flexibility.
He expressed a problem with the renewal section and
suggested it include an update of federal and state law and
a demonstration of competence. Another option would be to
require the department to notify permittees by certified
mail of any changes of the law within thirty days of the
effective date.
BRUCE OCKRASSA testified in support of SB 141. He believed
that concealed carry laws were saving lives by reducing
violent crime.
MIKE CORKILL, Alaska Peace Officers Association, spoke to
two provisions they had requested. He supported including
police officers both within the state and from out-of-state.
Retired peace officers had already received extensive
training and he supported the waiver of some of the
permitting process. He did not believe reciprocity for out-
of-state permittees should be recognized across the board
because other states permitting process was not as stringent
as Alaska's. He also firmly believed that no convicted
felon should ever be allowed to apply for a permit. He
supported fees remaining the same.
Kenai:
PHIL NASH, Attorney, stated the fee issue was a non-issue.
He noted that copies of current law were already provided in
instructional classes. He referred to the repealer brought
up earlier and explained that it would not affect anything.
He supported reciprocity in order to allow Alaskans to
carry concealed outside the state. He opposed the
provisions for former administrative police officers, but
not for "street cops." A special rule would perpetuate a
"them and us mentality."
ROD CHRISTOPHER, Instructor, Peninsula Weapons Academy,
supported the provision for retired police officers, but
believed they should take the law enforcement class to be
brought up to date. Regarding restaurants serving alcohol,
he believed that as long as a permittee stayed in the
restaurant part of the establishment and did not consume
alcohol, he should be allowed to carry a handgun in there.
He believed the qualifications standards for classes should
be raised.
Homer:
PATRICK JOHNSON, Law Enforcement Alliance of America,
supported the inclusion of retired police officers, training
requirements and reciprocity with other states.
Valdez: JOE MICHAUD, Police Chief, Valdez Police Department,
expressed his appreciation for the response to law
enforcement personnel about some of their concerns. He
briefly addressed the issue of reciprocity and spoke in
favor of it.
Barrow:
BILL JONES testified in support of the bill. He supported
carrying concealed in restaurants rather than having to
leave the weapon in a vehicle. He also supported the
reciprocity provision for protection for Alaskans traveling
out-of-state.
GREGG OLSON, Training Officer, Gun Club, supported SB 141.
He appreciated the exemption for former police officers. He
briefly addressed training of the legal portion of the
permitting process.
SCOTT CAMPBELL, Police Chief, North Slope Borough, supported
the bill and appreciated the inclusion of police officers.
He urged passage of the bill.
HARRIS STUERMER testified in support, particularly the
restaurant provision and the reciprocity provision.
Kodiak:
DIANA BUFFINGTON, District Chair, Republican Party,
supported SB 141 because she had been a rape victim and felt
women should be able to protect themselves. It would reduce
domestic violence. She believed women particularly needed
the law and it would make it easier to enact Second
Amendment rights.
Kenai:
BOB WISEMAN supported the legislation for law-abiding
citizens. He didn't support giving special privileges to
former law enforcement officers. He supported reciprocity.
He suggested using the commercial drivers' .04 blood alcohol
level guideline for concealed carry permitting.
RAYMOND CARR, Instructor, RNS Protection Services, testified
in favor of SB 141 as written.
The following individuals testified in person in Juneau:
DUANE BUELL, Owner, Sporting Goods Store, Juneau, supported
SB 141. He believed the bill was good for the permitting
process. Reciprocity was a non-issue in that history in
other states show now problems. He supported legal training
for retired police officers.
DICK BISHOP, Executive Director, Alaska Outdoor Council,
stated the council's support for the adopted version CSSB
141(FIN). He supported consideration for ensuring retired
police officers be kept current on laws.
DEL SMITH, Deputy Commissioner, Department of Public Safety
(DPS), testified that the concealed law was working well.
There were 6,325 permittees as of 4/11/97. No permits had
been rescinded for bad acts because of the effective
screening process. He brought up a concern about rescinding
the list of places where individuals were not allowed to
carry concealed weapons as it related to domestic violence
shelters. He supported meeting Alaska standards regarding
reciprocity. In response to a question from SENATOR ADAMS
regarding a thirty-day time period, he stated they could not
get the necessary information from the FBI in that amount of
time. They could take up to five months in getting back
with a report, so they conduct a statewide check. If there
is not indication of a problem, they submit the fingerprints
to the FBI and issue a conditional permit. The average time
was thirty days from the point of application to the
issuance of a permit.
SENATOR TORGERSON noted a provision referencing existing
statute that municipalities and villages could have a local
election opting to exclude concealed weapons. He inquired
if there were any existing. MR. SMITH was not aware of any.
LAUREE HUGONIN, Executive Director, Council on Domestic
Violence and Sexual Assault, DPS, expressed concern with
Sections 10, 13 and 15. Section 10 reduced the restrictions
for qualifying permitees. She believed it was vague and
referred to AS 12.55.015, noting that someone could still be
eligible to possess a handgun. The court may order a
forfeiture, but didn't have to. She also had concern that
there was no list under AS 11.61.200 and believed federal
law was not expansive enough to cover what was needed.
ART SNOWDEN, Administrative Director, Alaska Court System,
did not have a position. He suggested adding a section to
prohibit the carrying of firearms in a judicial facility,
with the exception of police officers, security guards and
those that were part of evidence.
End SFC-97 #115, Side 2
Begin SFC-97 #116, Side 1
In response to a question from SENATOR PARNELL, MR. SNOWDEN
acknowledged that there was a court rule prohibiting
firearms, but no law. People generally didn't know court
rules and he believed a law would be appropriate. SENATOR
ADAMS asked about federal laws. MR. SNOWDEN responded that
there was a federal law that bans firearms in federal court,
but it did not apply to state court.
SENATOR ADAMS brought up concerns regarding people with
alcohol and drug problems and the repealer section
concerning training.
MR. BABCOCK explained the repealer applied only to renewal,
it was still a requirement for the original permit.
Regarding the first concern, a person prohibited from
possessing a handgun under state or federal law would also
be prohibited from applying for a concealed carry permit.
He referred to the 3/24/97 memo regarding the standards that
would apply. There was additional discussion among SENATORS
PARNELL, PHILLIPS, GREEN, ADAMS and MR. BABCOCK regarding
clarification of the repealers section.
ANN CARPENETI, Assistant Attorney General, Criminal
Division, Department of Law, explained the that a revision
in the penalty section eliminated a B misdemeanor for
carrying where prohibited, but did not provide a
corresponding violation. SENATOR ADAMS believed there
should be a penalty.
COCHAIR SHARP asked if there would be forthcoming
amendments. SENATORS ADAMS and PHILLIPS affirmed they would
be proposing amendments. In response, COCHAIR SHARP
announced that the bill would be HELD for further
consideration.
| Document Name | Date/Time | Subjects |
|---|