Legislature(2025 - 2026)BELTZ 105 (TSBldg)
03/11/2025 01:30 PM Senate COMMUNITY & REGIONAL AFFAIRS
Note: the audio
and video
recordings are distinct records and are obtained from different sources. As such there may be key differences between the two. The audio recordings are captured by our records offices as the official record of the meeting and will have more accurate timestamps. Use the icons to switch between them.
Audio | Topic |
---|---|
Start | |
SB111 | |
SB102 | |
Adjourn |
* first hearing in first committee of referral
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
*+ | SB 111 | TELECONFERENCED | |
*+ | SB 102 | TELECONFERENCED | |
*+ | SB 26 | TELECONFERENCED | |
SB 111-DIGITAL PRODUCT REPAIR 1:33:25 PM CHAIR MERRICK announced the consideration of SENATE BILL NO. 111 "An Act relating to the diagnosis, maintenance, and repair of products that use digital electronics to operate; adding an unlawful act to the Alaska Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Act; and providing for an effective date." CHAIR MERRICK invited the bill sponsor to put himself on the record to introduce SB 111. 1:33:45 PM SENATOR DUNBAR, speaking as sponsor, introduced SB 111. He said the bill addresses challenges with digital products whose manufacturers do not make repair tools available. Many products cannot be repaired by the owner due to proprietary software, glued components, or special tools withheld by the manufacturer, forcing customers to use licensed dealers. Such dealers are often unavailable in Alaska, particularly rural areas. He said this can cause actual health and safety challenges. SENATOR DUNBAR stated that although "right to repair" legislation is still in the early stages, multiple states have introduced it, including Oregon, Colorado, and New York. SB 111 incorporates provisions from the best parts of those bills and invited testifiers will provide technical details. 1:35:41 PM SENATOR DUNBAR said Alaskans are independent, self-sufficient individuals, who like to repair their vehicles and devices. Particularly those who live off the road system or in a rural area where there are not many other options. He cited Caterpillar and John Deere as examples where large equipment failures can leave owners waiting weeks or months for repairs. He noted that owners cannot let an independent mechanic service that equipment. Such delays are impractical for farmers and independent mining operations. He expressed hope Alaska will join other states in adopting the "right to repair" trend. 1:36:49 PM CHAIR MERRICK announced invited testimony on SB 111. 1:37:03 PM ELIZABETH CHAMBERLAIN, Director of Sustainability, iFixit, San Luis Obispo, California, testified by invitation in support of SB 111. She described iFixit as a repair company that provides over 115,000 step-by-step repair guides for products ranging from toasters to tractors, and sells parts and tools so individuals can fix products themselves. She said one in fifteen Alaskans used iFixit last year, and the company also sells parts and tools wholesale to independent repair shops. In recent years, iFixit has partnered with manufacturers to provide original parts to customers, in some cases to comply with right to repair laws. She noted that iFixit is now the official parts distributor for Google Pixel, Microsoft Xbox, Logitech, and others. MS. CHAMBERLAIN said both consumers and independent repair shops report difficulty in obtaining spare parts. Some products, such as vacuum cleaners and fitness trackers, have no replacement parts available, while others have only a limited range of parts. She gave an example involving a Dyson hairdryer with a faulty power switch. She was unable to locate the needed part. She reached out to an independent repair shop, and it was unable to locate that particular part too. When she contacted Dyson for an out-of-warranty repair, she was told to buy a new hairdryer. She stated that manufacturers can push consumers to purchase new products when the manufacturer is not required to share repair parts. 1:39:39 PM MS. CHAMBERLAIN said iFixit supports electronics right to repair legislation nationwide and noted that five states have enacted such laws. She said many manufacturers do not comply, even where laws have passed, and especially in states where these laws have not passed. Even though right to repair is gaining traction, the pressure needs to continue to ensure Americans can get the repair access they need. She stated that Alaskans deserve the same access that is guaranteed by law to consumers in California, New York, Minnesota, Oregon, and Colorado. She said extending the lifespan of electronics benefits: the consumers pocketbook; the environment; the reduction of waste; the conservation of raw materials; and the prevention of toxic byproducts from manufacturing. She said it takes about 34 years of use for a cell phone to consume as much energy as is required to make it, and extending product lifespans helps avoid contributing to the 53 million tons of new electronic waste generated each year. She expressed support for SB 111 as a sound compromise that works for all interests. 1:41:26 PM CHAIR MERRICK said the testifier raised a good point about enforcement and asked what type of enforcement or recourse is available to uphold a consumer's legal right to repair. 1:41:41 PM HAHLEN BEHNKEN, Intern, Senator Forrest Dunbar, Alaska State Legislature, Juneau, Alaska, replied that it would be enforced as violations of other unfair trade practices are enforced under that Act. He referenced Section 3 of the sectional analysis, which states: Section 3. Amends AS 45.50.471(b) by adding violations of SB 111 Digital Product Repair statutes AS 45.45.800-45.45.890 to the list of unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices declared to be unlawful." MR. BEHNKEN said he would provide additional details in writing. 1:42:20 PM CHAIR MERRICK said that would be helpful information. 1:42:24 PM SENATOR DUNBAR expressed his belief enforcement would fall to the Civil Division of the Department of Law and said he will get back to the chair with that information. 1:42:45 PM JOE TORMA, General Manager, Green Star of Interior Alaska, Fairbanks, Alaska, testified by invitation in support of SB 111. He stated that Green Star is a nonprofit organization whose mission is to encourage waste reduction and increase recycling in Fairbanks North Star Borough (FNSB) communities. In 2017, Green Star obtained an electronics recycling contract for FNSB and, in 2020, began operating the central recycling facility in Fairbanks. He said Green Star also serves as the regional coordinator for Zender Environmental Backhaul Alaska, which removes end-of-life electronics from rural communities. He commented that he sees end of life electronics all day every day. MR. TORMA said one of Green Star's main initiatives is "Reuse It," a retail store selling refurbished laptops, desktops, network components, TVs, and small appliances, either repaired or dropped off in working order. The organization also offers a Rebuild IT" computer class to teach young people how to assemble computers from reclaimed parts, keeping products out of the landfill and providing an alternative to buying new. 1:44:55 PM MR. TORMA said this is the Alaskan way, especially in the Interior where parts, tools, and documentation are sometimes unavailable, and the ability to keep items working is part of daily living. Without access to parts, many items received are ground up and reclaimed rather than repaired and reused. He reiterated Green Star's support for SB 111. He suggested amending the bill language to clarify that tools and documentation should remain freely available to independent repair shops, even if a manufacturer can no longer obtain original replacement parts. He said that, if possible, there should be no restriction on obtaining parts from secondary sources and that Green Star relies heavily on reclaimed and third-party parts. 1:46:39 PM CHAIR MERRICK said the committee will take his testimony into consideration. She said she has dealt with this issue as have others and it is very frustrating. 1:47:17 PM CHAIR MERRICK held SB 111 in committee.