Legislature(1993 - 1994)

04/08/1993 03:40 PM RES

Audio Topic
* first hearing in first committee of referral
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
                   SENATE RESOURCES COMMITTEE                                  
                          April 8, 1993                                        
                            3:40 p.m.                                          
  MEMBERS PRESENT                                                              
  Senator Mike Miller, Chairman                                                
  Senator Loren Leman, Vice Chairman                                           
  Senator Steve Frank                                                          
  Senator Drue Pearce                                                          
  Senator Fred Zharoff                                                         
  MEMBERS ABSENT                                                               
  Senator Al Adams                                                             
  Senator Dave Donley                                                          
  COMMITTEE CALENDAR                                                           
  SENATE BILL NO. 103                                                          
  "An Act relating to air quality control  and the prevention,                 
  abatement, and control  of air pollution; and  providing for                 
  an effective date."                                                          
  HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION NO. 16                                           
  Relating to establishing the coal policy of the state.                       
  PREVIOUS SENATE COMMITTEE ACTION                                             
  SB 103 - See Resources minutes dated 2/17/93.                                
  HCR 16 - No previous action to record.                                       
  WITNESS REGISTER                                                             
  Russell Heath, Director                                                      
  Alaska Environmental Lobby                                                   
  P.O. Box 22151                                                               
  Juneau, Alaska 99802                                                         
  POSITION STATEMENT:  Opposed SB 103.                                         
  Aimee Boulanger                                                              
  Alaska Center for the Environment                                            
  519 W 8th Ave., Suite 201                                                    
  Anchorage, Alaska 99501                                                      
  POSITION STATEMENT:  Opposed SB 103.                                         
  Eric Myers                                                                   
  6710 Potter Heights                                                          
  Anchorage, Alaska 99516                                                      
  POSITION STATEMENT:  Opposed SB 103.                                         
  Resa Jerrel                                                                  
  National Federation of Independent Businesses                                
  9159 Skywood Lane                                                            
  Juneau, Alaska 99801                                                         
  POSITION STATEMENT:  Supported SB 103.                                       
  Bob Stiles                                                                   
  Alaska Coal Association                                                      
  1227 W 9th, No. 201                                                          
  Anchorage, Alaska 99501                                                      
  POSITION STATEMENT:  Supported HCR 16.                                       
  Charlie Boddy                                                                
  Alaska Miners Association                                                    
  1129 Kodiak Street                                                           
  Fairbanks, Alaska 99709                                                      
  POSITION STATEMENT:  Supported HCR 16.                                       
  ACTION NARRATIVE                                                             
  TAPE 93-20, SIDE A                                                           
  Number 001                                                                   
  SENATOR  MILLER called  the Resources  Committee  meeting to                 
  order at 3:40 p.m. and announced  SB 103 AIR QUALITY CONTROL                 
  to be up for consideration.                                                  
  RUSSELL HEATH, Director, Alaska Environmental Lobby, opposed                 
  SB 103, because he said it is  not the bill that was crafted                 
  by the working  committee last year which  they participated                 
  in and supported.                                                            
  He opposed SB 103,  because it fails to protect  the quality                 
  of Alaska's air,  restricts the public's right  to influence                 
  public policy, and restricts the rights of local governments                 
  to control the quality  of the air in their  own communities                 
  and  neighborhoods.   Also,  the  fee  structure  in SB  103                 
  subverts  the key  intent of the  Clean Air Act  which is to                 
  reduce emissions.  Logically, the size  of the fee should be                 
  tied to the amount emitted, but in SB 103 it  is tied to the                 
  per-hour cost to DEC to process the permit application which                 
  encourages letter-perfect applications, not less pollution.                  
  MR. HEATH stated that  he was not allowed to  participate at                 
  the Senate Resources subcommittee level  and said there were                 
  provisions in this  legislation that make it  impossible for                 
  state  or  local  governments  to  require  standards   more                 
  stringent than those required by the federal Clean Air Act.                  
  Number 243                                                                   
  SENATOR  LEMAN said he  was one of the  three members of the                 
  subcommittee and didn't see their work  as being in favor of                 
  any industry.   He thought SB 103  was a very fair  bill and                 
  that a representative from his  organization would have been                 
  invited if they had asked to attend.  SENATOR MILLER agreed.                 
  Number 243                                                                   
  SENATOR  LEMAN moved to adopt the CS  to SB 103 for purposes                 
  of  discussion.   There  were no  objections  and it  was so                 
  Number 244                                                                   
  AIMEE BOULANGER, Community Coordinator for Pollution  Issues                 
  for the Alaska Center for the  Environment, said this is not                 
  the bill they had originally supported.  They cannot support                 
  SB 103.  She said she  did attend the subcommittee's meeting                 
  while they  were working on SB 103, but  she did not feel it                 
  was appropriate to interrupt their meeting  to comment.  The                 
  public has been  cut out of  the process of influencing  the                 
  course of progress in their own neighborhoods and cut out of                 
  the process of deciding what is an acceptable risk for their                 
  own families.                                                                
  SB 103 does not create an  incentive or rewards for business                 
  to  prevent  pollution,  she  continued.    Section  010  is                 
  absolutely  unacceptable  for  the  basic  health  needs  of                 
  Number 340                                                                   
  SENATOR MILLER  commented that  if she  would have  asked to                 
  come to the table, she would have been welcome.                              
  ERIC MYERS, Anchorage, said he served on the DEC Air Quality                 
  Advisory  Work  Group  as a  representative  of  the general                 
  public.  He  said the timber  industry did  not act in  good                 
  faith to come to reach a consensus.  Subsection  (c) 2 which                 
  requires  that a  proposed standard  is  technologically and                 
  economically feasible, he commented, restricts what  is good                 
  for  the  public health  and well  being  and should  not be                 
  dictated by whether  it is economically feasible  - although                 
  it would probably be a rare instance.                                        
  SENATOR  FRANK  commented that  if  you  are going  to  shut                 
  businesses down, the legislature should be  in a position to                 
  make  that policy determination  rather than just abrogating                 
  that   authority  and   responsibility  to   the  regulating                 
  authority.  MR. MYERS said clean air should not be raised to                 
  an absolute standard of being economically feasible.                         
  Number 433                                                                   
  RESA JERREL, National  Federation of Independent Businesses,                 
  said normally she is not involved in this type of issue, but                 
  in 1991 she  put it out as a ballot question to her members.                 
  The question being, should DEC  regulations be restricted to                 
  federal standards?   Sixty  one percent  came back and  said                 
  yes, they should be restricted to just the federal standard.                 
  She said the Governor's Task  Force on Regulatory Reform  in                 
  March recommended  all departments be  restricted to federal                 
  standards.  She supported Sections 010 and 015 particularly.                 
  Number 454                                                                   
  SENATOR FRANK  asked  what the  remaining percentages  were.                 
  MS. JERREL replied  that 61% said yes,  33% no, and  6% were                 
  SENATOR FRANK moved to pass CS to SB 103 from committee with                 
  individual recommendations and asked for unanimous  consent.                 
  There were no objections and it was so ordered.                              
  Number 463                                                                   
  to be up for consideration.                                                  
  BOB  STILES,  President,  Alaska   Coal  Association  (ACA),                 
  supported HCR 16, because the policy  reflects the work of a                 
  lot of the membership of the ACA as well as other industrial                 
  organizations throughout the state.  This legislation  sends                 
  a  message to  the  international  investment community  and                 
  international customers for  Alaskan coal  that Alaska is  a                 
  good place to  do business.  This perception is tremendously                 
  important and of value to the long-term future of the state.                 
  Number 490                                                                   
  SENATOR FRANK asked if  he expected a domestic market  to be                 
  viable?  MR. STILES replied yes, that the domestic market is                 
  in  two  places  -  Hawaii,  which  is  currently  importing                 
  Indonesian coal, and in the state of Washington.                             
  SENATOR FRANK asked what the  chances for waiving the  Jones                 
  Act were.  MR. STILES said there are numerous waivers to the                 
  Jones Act. The State Ferry System has a waiver to  the Jones                 
  Act, for instance.  He believes  there is a good possibility                 
  of getting a Jones Act exemption  and, given that exemption,                 
  opens some  potential markets to  Alaskan coal that  are not                 
  now available to us.                                                         
  Number 508                                                                   
  CHARLIE  BODDY,  Alaska Coal  Association and  Alaska Miners                 
  Association, said they supported HCR 16.                                     
  SENATOR LEMAN moved to discharge HCR  16 from committee with                 
  individual  recommendations  and  accompanying fiscal  note.                 
  There were no objections and it was so ordered.                              
  SENATOR MILLER adjourned the meeting at 4:20 p.m.                            

Document Name Date/Time Subjects